Tennessee Criminal Attorney Blog
November 7, 2023

Legalization vs. Decriminalization: What’s the Difference for Defendants?


Marijuana Lay, TN Criminal Defense Firm

The discourse around the legalization and decriminalization of marijuana in the United States continues to evolve. Numerous states have decided to permit the use of medical marijuana, with other states going even further by allowing its recreational use.  

  While this debate continues, the terms legalization and decriminalization are often used interchangeably. However, they remain two distinct approaches to regulating behavior.  

  The subtleties of these two legal concepts are intricate, and the implications for defendants can be extensive. Having a defense lawyer who is versed in Tennessee marijuana law, like those at M. Don Himmelberg & Associates, can be the difference between navigating the legal system successfully and facing substantial penalties. 

Legalization vs. Decriminalization 

Legalization refers to the process where activities, previously deemed illegal, are made legal by government statute. This means no penalties, criminal or otherwise, for individuals involved in the now-legal activity. Decriminalization, on the other hand, does not make the activity entirely legal. Instead, it removes criminal penalties, replacing them with civil penalties, like fines. It is akin to downgrading the offense from a criminal act to something more like a traffic ticket. 

Legalization in Context 

When a substance or action is legalized, it means individuals can use or possess it without fearing criminal prosecution. However, it also usually means the implementation of a regulatory framework governing its use, production, and sale, ensuring public safety and health. 

  For example, several states have legalized the recreational use of marijuana, establishing regulations and taxes like those placed on alcohol. In these states, adults can possess, sell, or buy marijuana without facing any penalties, within the set legal limits. Any violation of the set legal limits could still result in penalties, but mere possession or use is not a criminal act. 

Decriminalization in Context 

Decriminalization does not make the act legal; it merely changes the consequences. A decriminalized act typically results in a civil penalty, like a fine, instead of criminal charges or incarceration. This approach aims to reduce the burden on the criminal justice system and focuses on rehabilitation and education instead of punishment. 

  This would mean that an individual caught with a decriminalized substance would face lesser penalties and could avoid a criminal record. When a substance is decriminalized, possession might not lead to a prison sentence but could result in a fine. So, for instance, if you are caught with a small amount of marijuana in a state where it is decriminalized, you might face a penalty, but you will not be labeled a criminal.  

Why Does This Distinction Matter for Criminal Defendants?  

A criminal conviction can have a lasting impact on one’s life. Apart from a criminal record and penalties such as jail, probation, community service, etc., a criminal conviction can affect your ability to secure employment, housing, and more. On the other hand, civil penalties, while often costly, do not come with the same lasting consequences. 

With drug laws and many other regulations continually evolving, defendants need a seasoned lawyer to guide them through the legal process. By hiring an experienced Tennessee criminal defense lawyer, Nashville defendants can ensure that they understand the nuances and implications of activities, previously deemed illegal, being legalized or decriminalized. 

 Though marijuana remains illegal in Tennessee, the movement toward either decriminalization or legalization is gaining traction in many other parts of the U.S., so it is vital to stay informed and understand your rights and obligations.  

How Can M. Don Himmelberg & Associates Help? 

While marijuana use might be gaining acceptance in other parts of the U.S., in Tennessee, it remains illegal. Even the possession of a small amount of marijuana can result in grave consequences under marijuana laws in Tennessee. Those found in possession of half an ounce or less can face misdemeanor charges, possible incarceration, and hefty fines.  

  The sale and distribution of marijuana carry even stiffer penalties, potentially leading to felony charges, long-term imprisonment, and substantial fines. What is more, the narrow scope of allowable medical conditions and stringent qualifications make legal accessibility to medicinal marijuana exceedingly restrictive. 

  A knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer can help explain the marijuana laws Tennessee defendants need to understand to protect their rights. In addition, a criminal defense lawyer in Tennessee from our law firm can assist in negotiating a plea deal or reduced sentence, or depending on the specifics of the case, manage to have the charges dropped. 

  Moreover, our lawyers’ knowledge of the local courts, judges, and prosecutors can be instrumental in navigating the legal intricacies surrounding marijuana laws in Tennessee

Contact a Tennessee Criminal Defense Lawyer at M. Don Himmelberg & Associates 

Facing legal uncertainties? Need clarification on legalization versus decriminalization in Tennessee? Reach out to M. Don Himmelberg & Associates for a consultation and let us unravel your legal concerns together! 

  Whether you are facing criminal or civil charges or simply need advice, our team is here to help you navigate the legal process and ensure that your rights are protected and that you are given the fair chance you deserve. 

  We can help you understand the complexities of the law and navigate through them with ease. Whether you are facing a criminal or civil offense in Tennessee, we are here to guide you every step of the way. Reach out to us today to schedule an initial consultation. 

Categorized as General